The 12 Best Panfish Flies – Your Ultimate Fly Selection Guide

best panfish flies

Fly Fisher Pro is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

Considering trying your hand at panfish fly fishing? You’ve come to the right place! We’ve carefully curated a list of the top 12 panfish flies to get you started on this thrilling adventure.

Fly fishing for panfish is a riveting experience filled with excitement and fun. Whether you’re targeting bluegill, crappies, rock bass, or yellow perch, these fish species are abundant across the US. They’re known for their curiosity, voracious appetites, and they’re famously unfussy eaters. Not to mention, they’re fierce fighters, ensuring every fishing trip is an adventure to remember.

The 12 Best Panfish Flies

Whether you’re a beginner testing the waters of bluegill fly fishing or a seasoned angler, these fly patterns won’t let you down:

Elk Hair Caddis

Elk Hair Caddis

Check Amazon US/UK Price

This phenomenal dry fly was first crafted by Al Troth, a pioneer in fly tying, in 1957. The Elk Hair Caddis is exceptionally effective in shallow water or near water structures. Once you use it, you’ll be in awe of the number of fish it helps you land.

J’s Grinchworm

J's Grinchworm

This vibrant and flashy pattern is a guaranteed lure for bluegill, perch, and even trout. The J’s Grinchworm, with its eye-catching chartreuse color and lifelike movement, is irresistible to panfish. Its jointed body and rubber legs create a convincing sense of motion underwater that fish find hard to resist.

Triangle Bug

Triangle Bug

The Triangle Bug is a subtly effective dry fly pattern that sits high in the water. Its long, rubber legs create a tempting silhouette for fish, making it appear like a juicy morsel. The Triangle Bug’s unique design makes it easy to remove from a bluegill’s tiny mouth, making your fishing experience smoother and more enjoyable.

McGinty Wet Fly

McGinty Wet Fly

Check Amazon US/UK Price

The McGinty Wet Fly, a classic favorite among trout anglers, works wonders with panfish as well. With its striking black and yellow coloring, this fly is highly visible in murky conditions, and it’s a favorite among sunfish. Its origins as a largemouth bass pattern explain its impressive performance in warm water. This killer pattern has been around since 1883, and it’s still a top performer.

Clouser Minnow

Clouser Deep Minnow Streamer

Check Amazon US/UK Price

The Clouser Minnow is a versatile streamer pattern, especially effective when fishing for perch and crappie. Its shimmering underwater movement makes it an irresistible lure for bluegill and other sunfish. Remember to opt for smaller sizes to accommodate the panfish’s tiny mouths.

Soft Hackle Wet Fly

Soft Hackle Wet Fly

Check Amazon US/UK Price

The Soft Hackle Wet Fly is a must-have for any panfish fishing expedition. Once you master your presentation, you’ll be amazed by the number of fish you catch with this versatile fly. It may not be as exciting as surface fishing, but if you’re after quantity, the Soft Hackle Wet Fly won’t disappoint.

Foam Spider

Foam Spider

Check Amazon US/UK Price

Foam Spiders are a fantastic choice for bluegill and sunfish. Their subtle but lifelike movement attracts fish of all kinds. Cast one near submerged structures, follow with a twitch and pause, and you’re almost guaranteed a catch.

Woolly Worm

Woolly Worm

Check Amazon US/UK Price

The Woolly Worm, the precursor to the popular Woolly Bugger, is an incredibly versatile fly pattern. Its design enables it to mimic aquatic insects like hellgrammites and stoneflies, making it a favorite choice for fish.

Panfish Wiggler

Panfish Wiggler

The Panfish Wiggler, originally a steelhead fly, has been resized to fit into a bluegill’s mouth. This bead head fly swiftly reaches the strike zone and is a highly effective streamer for bluegill, perch, crappie, and more.

Green Eyed Damselfly Nymph

Green Eyed Damselfly Nymph

Check Amazon US/UK Price

Green Eyed Damselfly Nymphs are common across US waters, making them an ideal fly for panfish. This pattern consistently delivers high performance and will help you reel in plenty of fish.

F-C Mackie Bug

F-C Mackie Bug

The F-C Mackie Bug, despite its odd appearance, is an excellent pattern that consistently nets results. Its flashiness and plumpness make it an irresistible lure for fish.

Floating Popper

Topwater Popper

Check Amazon US/UK Price

Floating Poppers have a simple design but are highly effective. Their satisfying plop onto the water’s surface instantly attracts nearby fish, making them a popular choice for bluegill fishing.

Conclusion and Call to Action

Fly fishing for bluegills is a fantastic experience, and knowing which flies to stock up on for your fly boxes can greatly enhance your success rate. From the Woolly Bugger to the Elk Hair Caddis and the Panfish Wiggler, these are some of the most effective flies for panfish.

All you need to get started is your fly rod and these fly patterns. With panfish being abundant and found all over, you’re likely to find an excellent fishing spot not far from you. We’d love to hear about your experiences and which fly patterns work well for you, so drop us a comment or email to let us know!

If you found this panfish fly guide helpful, why not share it on Facebook or Twitter? Also, don’t miss our other guides to the top fly rods, reels, fly lines, and accessories for fly fishing on the blog.

And finally, if you’re looking to enhance your fly fishing knowledge further, don’t forget to download our series of fly fishing books below.

Save Up To 50% At Trident Fly Fishing

We’ve partnered with Trident Fly Fishing to get you EXCLUSIVE DISCOUNTS on a huge selection of fly fishing gear. I highly recommend checking out their USED GEAR SECTION to save a ton on a premium rod and reel.

Trident Fly Fishing Deal

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top