The 10 Best Bonefish Flies – Fly Selection Guide

best bonefish flies

Fly Fisher Pro is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

Allow me to introduce you to 10 of the most effective bonefish flies you can use in the Bahamas, Florida and around the globe! As an experienced fly fisherman, I have a handful of favorites that have proven to be successful time and time again. The beauty of these flies is their versatility. They work marvelously for bonefish, but you can also use them for other species like triggerfish, trevally and permit. So, let’s dive into the world of bonefish flies and find out which ones you should have in your tackle box for your next adventure.

Bonefish Flies

Gotcha

gotcha

Check Trident Fly Fishing Price

The Gotcha is the Swiss army knife of bonefish flies. It’s a trusted companion that will rarely let you down, no matter where in the world you are fishing. The shrimp pink nose, tan overwing, and lots of flash material are simply too tempting for bonefish to resist.

To maximize your possibilities, fill your bonefish fly box with sizes 2 – 6, each in two weight variations. The lightweight version should have small bathroom chain eyes, while the heavy version can carry small tungsten dumbbell eyes.

Spawning Shrimp

Spawning Shrimp

Check Trident Fly Fishing Price

The Spawning Shrimp is your all-terrain vehicle in the world of shrimp flies. When choosing a color, match it to the bottom you are fishing over. For instance, use a light tan color over white sand and a brown or olive version over turtle grass.

The egg sack acts as a trigger point, and the silicone legs give the fly plenty of lifelike movement in the water. For most bonefish, I recommend a size 4 Spawning Shrimp, but if you’re targeting larger cruising bones, a slightly longer version could be more effective.

Avalon Shrimp

Check Trident Fly Fishing Price

The Avalon Shrimp is a sought-after Bahamas permit fly that replicates the long mantis shrimp found on the shallow sand and coral flats. Large bonefish in this area feed on the same shrimp, making a slightly smaller version of the Avalon an exceptional choice.

The Avalon stands out with two unique features: the zonker strips tied on the sides of the hook, which act as claws and give the fly incredible movement during retrieval, and the keel system that allows the fly to swim hook point up.

For your bonefish box, make sure you have size 4 and 2 Avalon Shrimps. If a permit happens to show up, you can confidently present the same fly to it.

Pseudo Shrimp

Pseudo Shrimp

The Pseudo Shrimp, despite being around for a while, still holds its own among my favorite flies. The fly’s action differs from others on the list due to the positioning of the weight on the hook.

It’s an excellent bonefish fly, whether you’re stripping it at speed or fishing it slowly.

Pink Puff

Pink Puff

Check Amazon US/UK Price

The Pink Puff is a classic that continues to deliver results. It may not be the first fly I tie to my leader on a new fishery, but it often saves the day when other flies don’t seem to hit the mark.

Its soft delivery is likely the key to its success. I always carry a few in my box, tied on size 6 hooks with small bathroom chain eyes.

Veverka Mantis Shrimp

Veverka Mantis Shrimp

Check Trident Fly Fishing Price

The Veverka Mantis Shrimp is very similar to the Spawning Shrimp. The main difference is the materials used and the legs pointing to the side of the fly. This fly pattern is best fished slowly or even static and looks very lifelike in the water.

I always have a good range of these flies in my box, from sizes 2 to 6 and in various weights. This allows me to target bonefish, triggerfish and small trevally species.

Christmas Island Special

Christmas Island Special

Check Trident Fly Fishing Price

The Christmas Island Special is a rendition of the popular Crazy Charlie. It resembles a Gotcha but uses a different overwing material.

When tying the fly, I prefer adding forward and rearward facing legs. This gives the fly good underwater movement, even when fished slowly. If the fish react poorly to the legs, I simply cut them off with my pliers or nippers.

The best sizes to have in your saltwater fly box are 4 and 6. As always, carry two or three different weight variations, wh