The Best Fly Fishing Subscription Box Reviews

fly fishing subscription box

Fly Fisher Pro is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

Are you tired of making frequent trips to the fly shop? What if you could get a box of fly fishing goodies delivered to your doorstep every month, tailored to your fishing preferences? I’ve done exhaustive research and testing to bring you the best fly fishing subscription boxes out there today:

  • The Fly Crate
  • Post Fly
  • Freestone Fly Fishing Company
  • iFlies
  • Lucky Tackle Box

the fly crate

Delve into Fly Crate Subscription Box

Firstly, let’s take a look at The Fly Crate subscription box, a promising monthly fly club and online fly shop based out of Pennsylvania. They offer top-quality flies, tips, and stickers every month. Not just that, they dedicate 2% of all subscription box sales to rehabilitate disabled veterans through their partnership with Project

Healing Waters, Inc.

How Does It Work?

You select your target species, either Trout or Bass, and voila, a new box of flies is delivered to you every month. They offer a discount on all of their current stock of nymphs, flies, and streamers for avid fishers like us. They offer three subscription plans that range from $14 to $24 per month. The higher-end subscription adds 12 flies to your tackle box a month. That’s 144 extra flies every year!

the fly crate

Flies Tailored To Your Location

The Fly Crate’s team, comprised of highly experienced anglers, ensures the flies selected for your subscription box are perfect for your area and the time of year. The founder, Nate, is as passionate about fly fishing as you and I are.

Inside the Box

The Lifestyle Plan for trout, for instance, includes 12 flies for trout, strike indicator pucks, a Chums Eyewear Retainer, a sticker, and a guide magazine. The Fly Crate offers a membership plan, which gives you a 15% off on everything in their store.

Member Reviews

The Fly Crate has been showered with positive reviews. One user praised their great leaders and sturdy, yet fooling fish flies. Another appreciated their well-tied flies and excellent customer service.

Alternative Subscription Boxes

Besides The Fly Crate, there are other online store subscriptions worth considering.

Post Fly

Postfly offers a premium subscription box that includes a small disposable tackle box with varying numbers of flies. They offer a double subscription box that includes twice the number of flies for $44.95. Check out their fishing subscription box at Post Fly.

Freestone Fly Fishing Company

Freestone’s subscription box costs $18.95 per month. They have fantastic reviews however, they do not focus on selecting flies expertly chosen for your area. Check out their fishing subscription box at Freestone Fly Fishing.


iFlies is a budget subscription box based out of the UK. They provide flies for trout, salmon, and warm water species, and send their subscription box all over the world every month. Check out their fishing subscription box at iFlies.

fly fishing box subscription

Our Recommendation

After a detailed analysis, The Fly Crate seems to offer the best balance of cost, quality, and local knowledge. We’ve partnered with The Fly Crate to provide our readers with double the flies on their first purchase. Just enter DOUBLETHEFLIES at checkout to avail of this special deal and kickstart your fly fishing journey!

In conclusion, fly fishing subscription boxes provide a fantastic way to discover new gear, try out latest fly patterns, and keep your fly boxes full. Plus, it saves you a trip to the fly shop. So why wait? Dip your toes in the exciting world of fly fishing with these subscription boxes. Don’t forget to download our series of fly fishing books below for even more insights and tips.

Save Up To 50% At Trident Fly Fishing

We’ve partnered with Trident Fly Fishing to get you EXCLUSIVE DISCOUNTS on a huge selection of fly fishing gear. I highly recommend checking out their USED GEAR SECTION to save a ton on a premium rod and reel.

Trident Fly Fishing Deal

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top