Interested in trying ice fishing? Need a pair of boots that will go with your new hobby?
When you’re dealing with extreme elements, it’s important to ensure that you are well-equipped and protected from the harshness of the weather. It can be difficult for anglers to buy the best ice fishing boots, which will thoroughly insulate feet without further ado. Here are some things to consider when picking out the right ice fishing boots for you.
Tips for Choosing the Best Ice Fishing Boots
When you go for ice fishing you want a product that helps in a majority of the aspects related to this activity. As such, careful consideration is needed when choosing an item to use as boots or alongside your ice fishing boots. You’ll naturally want to wear a product that protects you from the harsh cold conditions of the environment of ice fishing. Here are some things to consider.
A good ice fishing boot should not be complicated to put on or take off so that you don’t find yourself struggling with them frequently. Your boots should also not be so hefty or bulky that they make it hard for you to move around in. It’s already difficult to be quick when you are cold, so extra weight and bulk can create a hassle for you.
You will want to opt for a product that provides your feet with plenty of warmth to keep you comfortable throughout your fishing trip. Cold and frozen toes can make even the most fun activity terrible, so this should be a top priority. Your boots should also be waterproof so as to keep excess water, dirt, and other external disturbances from entering them and making your experience less pleasant.
You will be making your way through external conditions that can easily damage a low-quality product, so you need an item that will easily stand up to harsh conditions and last for a long time regardless. Boots should not crack or become torn too easily, as even the smallest leaks can let water and dirt into them and prevent them from keeping you warm.
The Top 5 Best Ice Fishing Boots Reviews
#1 Muck Boots Men's Arctic Pro Hunting Boots
These boots are fleece-lined for warmth and have been optimized for protection and dryness.
- Double reinforcements in terms of protective support are present at the instep, heel, and Achilles of the boot, allowing for a safer journey.
- They are comfortable even in rough weather, with a 2mm thermal foam underlay that keeps them warm and toasty.
- A pull-on design with a stretch-fit top line makes the boots easy to put on and take off.
- They are heavily insulated and waterproof to keep feet dry.
- The neoprene coating and rubber outer layer are rather thin and can cut and crack easily, leading to leaks, this lack of durability that makes it difficult to use for everyday wear or in more extreme weather situations.
- Soles may be slippery on icy surfaces that are hard and wet, which can cause trouble and pose safety issues.
- Sizing runs slightly inconsistent.
#2 Hotmocs Shoe/Boot Covers
This product is not exactly a pair of boots, but they function as shoe or boot covers to add protective features to footwear that you already currently own.
- The covers are easy to put on and remove, requiring no adjustments or bindings.
- They are compact and lightweight, making them easy to carry and bring around in a bag or as an emergency item.
- It functions through footwear of any weight and thickness.
- They keep feet warm even in extreme cold conditions.
- The insulation value mainly comes from heat packs attached to the covers, so once the heat packs cease to function, the covers may no longer work as intended.
- The actual insulation abilities of the cover itself leave much to be desired, as it is made
- Designed to be very thin and is not known to be of high-quality.
- The small size of the covers makes them difficult to fit over bulkier boots and may not be suitable for those with larger feet.
#3 Outdoor Research Men's Rocky Mountain High Gaiters
Once again, this item is not a boot in itself, but rather a pair of gaiters that can be attached to the lower legs over currently owned footwear to keep them warm, dry, and free of foreign objects.
- A simple, no-bulk design makes for easy packing and use, while also allowing users to walk with them unhindered and in complete comfort.
- It fits snugly over the legs and does not move or slip.
- It effectively keeps dirt and water out of the lower legs of boots and shoes, while also keeping the legs warm.
- High durability means they can be used again and again for a long time.
- The sizing runs small, making it difficult for those with larger calves to use them comfortably.
- They aren’t breathable, so you may find your lower legs gathering sweat or moisture in certain conditions.
#4 Korkers CastTrax Cleated Overshoe
These overshoes can be slipped under boots to provide traction in slippery areas, increasing levels of safety during an ice fishing expedition and working in even the slickest terrain.
- The overshoes are equipped with a quick-release buckle for easy removal and attachment.
- Each spike in the base of the shoe is very durable, but is replaceable in case of necessity, and the product itself comes with 10 emergency spikes.
- The walls of the shoe are well-molded to provide a close and secure fit.
- They work effectively on even extremely slippery surfaces.
- They aren’t designed for warmth, as their main function is to offer non-slip protection.
- Their design makes them heavy and bulky, causing more difficulty in movement.
So which ones are the best?
Let’s weight our options here.. The MuckBoots Men’s Arctic Pro Hunting Boot lacks in durability and may give out quickly, resulting in loss of warmth and waterproof features. The Hotmocs Shoe/Boot Covers lack in terms of quality, making it difficult to have confidence in. And while the Korkers CastTrax Cleated Overshoes may be an excellent product, they aren’t specifically designed for ice fishing and therefore have none of the necessary warmth or waterproofing.
In terms of functionality, the Outdoor Research Men's Rocky Mountain High Gaiters reign over the other products. Unlike the other products, it is known to be extremely durable and covers all the bases required for a good ice fishing boot product: it is warm, it is waterproof, it lasts long and can withstand a lot of abuse, and it isn’t too bulky to hinder movement. If you are searching for a product that will keep you dry and toasty even on the coldest of ice fishing expeditions, this may be the one for you.